Kalani Sitake Stays at BYU, Rejects Penn State’s Lucrative Offer

Kalani Sitake has decided to remain as the head coach of Brigham Young University (BYU), turning down a substantial offer from Penn State. This decision comes amid a competitive coaching landscape, where Penn State aimed to entice him with a lucrative contract to join the Big Ten Conference. Sitake’s choice reflects deep personal values and a commitment to BYU’s mission, emphasizing service and community over financial incentives.

In the weeks leading up to his decision, Sitake consulted an impressive advisory team, including Kansas City Chiefs coach Andy Reid and Hall of Fame quarterback Steve Young. During a national broadcast, Young passionately defended Sitake, asserting that if Penn State desired BYU’s coach, they would “have to rip him from our bloody hands.”

Equally influential in Sitake’s decision was Patti Edwards, widow of his late mentor, LaVell Edwards. Sitake sought her counsel during this pivotal time, reflecting on the importance of stability and commitment that LaVell exemplified throughout his storied career at BYU. Patti Edwards, now 93, emphasized the value of being part of a community that offers a sense of belonging and purpose.

While BYU did not disclose specific financial details, it confirmed that Sitake’s new contract includes a significant salary increase, surpassing previous compensation levels. Reports indicate that the offer from Penn State would have been worth millions more per year, yet Sitake prioritized his connection to BYU. He noted that a statement in the football team’s Student Athlete Building resonates deeply with him: “We follow the example of the toughest man to ever walk the earth, our Savior Jesus Christ.”

This philosophy underpins Sitake’s coaching approach, which integrates faith and football. He believes that service and compassion enhance the game, stating, “Football’s cool when the gospel’s in it.” His own journey reflects this belief; he credits the Edwards-led BYU football team with helping him through a challenging childhood, particularly during his parents’ divorce.

Sitake’s tenure at BYU has seen the team achieve a remarkable 23-3 record over the past two seasons, positioning them on the brink of a College Football Playoff berth. His commitment extends beyond the field, as evidenced by BYU’s recent community initiatives, such as raising $65,000 for a Texas Tech team member’s family following a serious accident.

The culture Sitake fosters within the program emphasizes “love and learning,” appealing to players from diverse backgrounds. Former walk-on and current team captain Tanner Wall expressed the profound impact Sitake has had on his life, stating, “Playing for Kalani has changed the trajectory of our lives.”

In his office following the announcement of his contract extension, Sitake articulated his broader mission. He sees his role as not just winning games but also fostering a culture of service that connects players to their communities and to their faith. “Serving others is an undefeated system and it’s always available,” he remarked, underscoring the importance of community engagement, even in the face of a loss.

The decision by Sitake comes amid ongoing discussions in college football about the ethics of coaching contracts and the pressures coaches face during the season. Some BYU fans expressed concern that Sitake’s job situation might overshadow the upcoming Big 12 Championship game, while others recognized the challenges posed by aggressive recruitment strategies from rival programs.

After months of speculation and negotiations, BYU administration, including President Shane Reese and Athletic Director Brian Santiago, played a crucial role in retaining Sitake. The new contract not only increases his salary but also enhances compensation for the entire coaching staff and includes commitments for name, image, and likeness (NIL) opportunities for players.

Sitake expressed his gratitude for the support he received from the BYU community during this process. He acknowledged the overwhelming positive response from fans and emphasized that he did not want his consideration of the Penn State position to detract from the team’s focus. “I didn’t want it to be a distraction,” he stated, apologizing to fans for any stress his situation may have caused.

As he prepares for the championship game, Sitake’s focus remains steadfast on his players and the values he holds dear. He stated, “I like who I am when I’m around BYU football and around BYU fans.” His commitment to maintaining a nurturing and spiritually enriching environment at BYU continues to resonate, positioning him as a leader who embodies the institution’s core values.

Kalani Sitake’s decision to stay at BYU underscores a profound commitment to community, faith, and the mission of the institution, reinforcing his role as a pivotal figure in the landscape of college football. His journey exemplifies the intersection of personal values and professional aspirations, making him a unique presence in today’s competitive coaching environment.