Urgent Update: ‘Romy & Michele’ Musical Bombs at Off-Broadway

UPDATE: The Off-Broadway musical adaptation of “Romy & Michele’s High School Reunion” has just opened at Stage 42, and early reviews are overwhelmingly negative. Critics are calling it a lackluster rendition that fails to capture the charm and humor of the beloved **1997 film**.

This adaptation, which first premiered in **Seattle in 2017**, stars well-known performers **Laura Bell Bundy** of “Legally Blonde” fame and **Kara Lindsay** from “Newsies.” However, audiences are finding it hard to connect, with reports of a show that feels “anemic” and devoid of the original’s anarchic spirit.

Why does this matter RIGHT NOW? The musical aims to draw fans of the film, but ticket prices are steep, reaching nearly **$100**. Many who attended the opening night described the experience as more painful than an actual high school reunion, where former classmates seem to have it all together while you’re left feeling out of place.

The show follows the story of two friends, Romy and Michele, who concoct fake identities to impress their old classmates at their **10-year high school reunion**. While the original film was celebrated for its humor and relatable themes, critics argue that this stage version lacks the necessary comedic timing and chemistry between the leads.

The score by **Gwendolyn Sanford** and **Brandon Jay** has been criticized for failing to evoke the late-1990s nostalgia. Instead of catchy anthems reminiscent of the era, the music falls flat, described as “generic Broadway pop.” The result is a production that misses the mark on emotional engagement and humor.

As the production unfolds, the set design has also drawn criticism for being overly digital and lacking visual depth, making it hard for audiences to become invested in the story. Critics have pointed out that the director, **Kristin Hanggi**, known for her successful work on “Rock of Ages,” has stumbled in creating a cohesive and entertaining experience.

The show’s potential was high, but the execution leaves much to be desired. With a cast of **10 performers**, including a standout performance by **Jordan Kai Burnett** as a goth rival, the musical struggles to find its footing.

In conclusion, “Romy & Michele The Musical” has opened to a wave of disappointment, and ticket sales may reflect this. For those looking for a nostalgic night out, this production may not be the reunion they were hoping for. What happens next is uncertain, but the buzz surrounding this show is likely to continue as audiences share their experiences.

Stay tuned for further updates on this developing story as we monitor the reception and potential changes in the production.